Wednesday, April 19, 2017

“Mere Life”: Possible Essay Questions




1.   Critically analyse the theological/messianic moment in Benjamin’s reflections on history and violence.

2.   Explore the theme of “natural history” in the writings of W G Sebald.

3.   Explore the concept of the “creatureliness” in the early novels of J M Coetzee’s. What is the philosophical import of this concept?

4.   Schmitt’s analysis of the  “state of exception” has played a significant role in post 9/11 political theory. Analyse the strengths of this contribution but also its possible weaknesses

5.   Todorov offers a robust contemporary defense of humanism. To what extent do you think his critical humanism meets the critical objections levels by the theorists of ‘mere life.”

6.   Explain Agamben’s derivation of the concept of “bare life” from Foucauldian bio-politics. Is his position authentically Foucauldian?

7.   Examine Agamben’s appropriation of Schmitt’s state of exception. Consider a democratic response to this analysis and evaluate the relative merits of both positions.

8.   Critically examine the creaturely dimension of Adorno and Horkheimer’s Dialectic of Enlightenment.

9.   Eric Santner suggests that Kafka belongs to the tradition of creaturely life. Critically evaluate the concept of the creaturely in Kafka’s short stories. Does he offer anything new to the themes already considered in our course?